Errol Flynn: The True Story of Australia's Hollywood Icon
by Patricia A. O’Brien
My rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Errol Flynn has long occupied that uneasy territory between history and mythology. To generations of filmgoers he remains the quintessential swashbuckler: the laughing rogue of Captain Blood and The Adventures of Robin Hood, forever preserved in Hollywood's golden age.
Patricia A. O'Brien's Errol Flynn: The True Story of
Australia's Hollywood Icon seeks neither to celebrate nor demolish that
legend. Instead, she attempts something more ambitious: to understand the man
behind it.
The result is an intelligent, deeply researched and often
compelling biography that places Flynn within the broader social, political and
cultural currents of the twentieth century. O'Brien's Flynn is not simply a
movie star but a product of empire, colonialism, privilege, celebrity and
self-invention.
Moving beyond familiar anecdotes of drinking, womanising and
adventure, she traces connections between his Tasmanian upbringing, his
experiences in New Guinea and the attitudes that later shaped both his career
and personal life.
One of the book's strengths is its refusal to reduce Flynn to hero or villain. O'Brien examines his racism, treatment of women, appetite for excess and the controversies that continue to shadow his reputation.
She neither embraces the romantic mythology Flynn cultivated nor
indulges in simplistic moral condemnation. Instead, she presents a complex
individual whose charisma and flaws were inseparable.
The biography is equally effective in restoring historical context. Flynn emerges not as an anomaly but as a figure shaped by imperial assumptions, shifting sexual politics and the evolving machinery of celebrity culture.
In doing so, O'Brien elevates the work beyond conventional film
biography and transforms it into a broader study of twentieth-century
masculinity and fame.
She is especially persuasive in challenging the notion that Flynn was little more than a handsome rogue who stumbled into stardom.
O'Brien argues that his acting ability has been underestimated and that his effortless screen presence concealed a more intelligent performer than critics have traditionally allowed.
There is considerable merit in the argument. Flynn
possessed a rare gift for making performance appear natural, quality audiences frequently mistook for a lack of technique.
But the history of Flynn's acting reputation is more complex
than a straightforward rehabilitation allows.
One example in this book is The Private Lives of Elizabeth and Essex (1939). During production, Bette Davis famously regarded Flynn as miscast, believing him incapable of matching the demands of a prestige historical drama and wishing Laurence Olivier had been cast instead.
What makes this fabled vignette even more fascinating (not covered by O'Brien) is
Davis's ultimate volte-face: revisiting the film years later, she reportedly
admitted to Olivia de Havilland: 'I was wrong, wrong, wrong. Flynn was
brilliant.'
The episode captures the enduring difficulty of assessing Flynn. His ease on screen often concealed the skill beneath it. O'Brien is right to argue that he deserves greater critical respect than he has received.
Yet the reservations voiced by Davis and others formed part of a genuine debate about whether Flynn was a great actor or simply an extraordinary screen presence.
His unique talent may have been making the distinction impossible to
separate.
O'Brien is also particularly adept at demonstrating the gap between Flynn's public persona and private reality. The familiar image of the carefree adventurer obscures a man who was frequently restless, self-destructive and acutely conscious of his own celebrity.
Throughout the
book, Flynn appears both beneficiary and victim of the mythology he helped
create. The very charisma that elevated him to international stardom also
trapped him within a public role from which he was never entirely able to
escape.
The one area I found less convincing is O'Brien's brusque dismissal
of longstanding rumours surrounding Flynn's bisexuality.
Her principal target in this dismantling process is Charles
Higham's controversial Errol Flynn: The Untold Story, a work of crass sensationalism
that has rightly attracted substantial criticism over the decades.
Yet O'Brien seems less interested in weighing the evidence
than in shutting down debate completely.
These rumours did not begin with Higham and have persisted through memoirs, biographies, industry anecdotes and insider commentary for decades. Some claims are undoubtedly weak. Others come from sources more difficult to dismiss outright.
None conclusively proves Flynn had encounters
with men, none conclusively disproves it.
Given the era in which he lived, definitive evidence was
always likely to be scarce. Homosexual acts were criminalised throughout much
of the English-speaking world, and even rumours could destroy careers and
reputations.
What stands out is not merely O'Brien's scepticism but her staunch tone of rebuttal and reluctance to dig further.
Consequently, the
reader is left with the impression not that the matter has been conclusively
settled, but that some aspects of Flynn's life remain inherently unknowable.
This points to what I see as the biography's principal limitation, which may leave some LGBTQIA+ readers feeling left out in the cold.
As a scrupulous academic, the author naturally veers towards certainty where the literary ambiguity of a less scholarly biographer may have been more illuminating. Yet ambiguity is central to Flynn's enduring fascination.
Was he a serious actor or merely an extraordinary screen
personality? A disciplined craftsman or a gifted opportunist? The evidence
points in multiple directions.
The biography's greatest achievement is its refusal to treat Flynn as a relic of old Hollywood, or a defendant standing trial before modern sensibilities. O'Brien understands that historical understanding requires not nostalgia nor condemnation, but curiosity.
Even where her
conclusions seem too certain, the questions she raises are worthwhile.
Errol Flynn: The True Story of Australia's Hollywood Icon remains an outstanding achievement. O'Brien combines rigorous scholarship with engaging narrative drive and succeeds in making Flynn relevant to contemporary readers.
By the book's conclusion, he emerges not as the romantic
adventurer of fanzine mythos nor the villain of revisionist caricature, but a
profoundly gifted, deeply flawed and endlessly contradictory man.
The finest compliment one can pay O'Brien is that she makes Flynn matter again. Even where its strongest conclusions invite debate, the biography succeeds in restoring complexity to a figure too often reduced to legend or scandal.
Some commentators have questioned the relevance of Errol Flynn in today's world. He was my parents' Saturday matinee idol at the kids' flicks. To me he is a link between Australian and Hollywood history, the subject of Australian Crawl's 1981 hit 'Errol' … and a man in tights impossible to look away from.
Patricia A. O'Brien has produced what will likely become the definitive modern account of Errol Flynn: richly researched, provocative and consistently engaging.
And deservedly won its 2026 NSW History Award.





.jpg)

